THE 10 BEST Restaurants in Garden City – Updated August 2021 – Tripadvisor

1. Waterzooi Belgian Bistro

392 reviews Closed Now


Belgian, Seafood$$ – $$$Menu

“Amazing seafood”

“Mussels Pot- divine!”

2. Seasons 52

438 reviews Closed Now

American$$ – $$$

“Entrees we had included Filet Mignon, L…”

“We had the Grilled plank salmon, salad…”

3. The Capital Grille

289 reviews Closed Now

American, Steakhouse$$$$

“… – special mention of the calamari with hot peppers, lump crab meat, lobst…”

“… Worcester sauce and his side lobster tail were perfectly cooked to his or…”

4. Grand Lux Cafe

293 reviews Closed Now

American, Bar$$ – $$$Menu

“… and found our salmon meal entrees t…”

“The Salmon Three Ways was delightful an…”

5. Ruth’s Chris Steak House

222 reviews Closed Now

American, Steakhouse$$$$Menu

“I had the steakhouse salad which comes with mixed greens, Italian dressing, r…”

“Sizzling crab cakes, loved them.”

6. La Nonna Bella

101 reviews Closed Now

Italian$$ – $$$Menu

“Top notch authentic Italian food”

“… are back in Puglia when we dine her…”

7. Thomas’s Ham & Eggery Diner

241 reviews Closed Now

American, Diner$

1.9 mi

Carle Place

“Breakfast Delight”

“Never disappoints”

See also  26 Tricks to stop your dog from digging up your yard

8. Vincent’s Clam Bar

433 reviews Closed Now

Italian, Seafood$$ – $$$

1.6 mi

Carle Place

[external_link offset=1]

“… and depending on the pick, it can also include, salad, and choice of pasta.”

“Their seafood, pasta and especially their sauce (shipped all over the world)…”

9. West End Cafe

217 reviews Closed Now

American$$ – $$$

1.8 mi

Carle Place

“My fav is the tuna and the flatbread.”

“Ahi tuna salad was rare and crusted nicely and the butternut squash ravioli w…”

10. Spuntino Wine Bar & Italian Tapas

140 reviews Closed Now

Italian, Wine Bar$$ – $$$Menu

“Seared tuna bruschetta was so good I had another one.”

“The lamb chops were seasoned very simply yet perfectly.”

11. Havana Central

252 reviews Closed Now

Caribbean, Latin$$ – $$$Menu

“I had the Cuban sandwich and it was delicious.”

“I had the Cuban Sandwich, you can’t have Havana in your restaurant name and n…”

12. Red Salt Room by David Burke

179 reviews Closed today

American, Contemporary$$$$Menu

“… makes u feel like you are on vacation.”

“… foie gras pasta didn’t seem to feat…”

13. Biscuits & Barbeque

116 reviews Closed Now

American, Barbecue$$ – $$$

1.3 mi


“Try the ribs, po boys, mac & cheese and don’t miss the Turtle pie for desert.”

See also  How to Make a Kitchen Planter Box for Herbs

“Consistently Awesome”

14. Grimaldi’s Pizza

168 reviews Closed Now

Pizza, Italian$$ – $$$Menu

“pizza, calzones, salad and more!!! all…”

“Also try the Grimaldi salad.”

15. Maggiano’s Little Italy

139 reviews Closed Now

Italian$$ – $$$Menu

“Warm wonderful service“”


16. Cafe Baci

344 reviews Closed Now

Italian$$ – $$$

2.9 mi


“Hits the spot”

“Very tasty Italian food”

17. Novita

142 reviews Closed Now

Italian, Wine Bar$$ – $$$Menu

“Lots of mixed seafood treats, lobster,…”

“Good Spot In Garden City”

18. Smok-Haus

25 reviews Closed Now

Bar, Barbecue$$ – $$$Menu

“… start with the ribs….fall off the…”

“Fantastic Restaurant”

19. Akbar Restaurant

78 reviews Closed Now

Indian, Asian$$ – $$$Menu

“Best Indian food”

“… bu they are fresh, good, tasty & they make their own naan (fresh)”

20. Orchid

81 reviews Closed Now

Chinese, Asian$$ – $$$

“Best on long island”

“good food, so so service”

[external_link offset=2]

21. Crabtrees Restaurant

241 reviews Closed Now

See also  How to Plant a Vegetable Garden in Sandy Soil

Seafood, Mediterranean$$ – $$$Menu

3.5 mi

Floral Park

“I studied the menu and really wanted the calamari plate and the escargot with…”

“Our friends had the grilled octopus and…”

22. BK Sweeney’s Uptown Grille

81 reviews Closed Now

American, Bar$$ – $$$Menu

“great lunch with girlfriends”

“Good Food, Nice Ambiance”

23. Calagero’s

68 reviews Closed Now

Italian$$ – $$$Menu

“First time did not disappoint”

“Fabulous meal and service excellent”

24. Small Batch

50 reviews Closed Now

American$$ – $$$Menu

“overpriced and very disappointing”

“Another boring Colicchio restaurant”

25. The Cuban

103 reviews Closed Now

Caribbean, Latin$$ – $$$Menu

“We also had the empanadas that were huge and delicious.”

“A slice of Cuba in Garden City!!!”

26. Seventh Street Cafe

129 reviews Closed Now

Italian$$ – $$$Menu

“My in-laws had Salmon and asked for it not cooked to thwor preference, also n…”

“Cute place sat outside food took about a half an hour for a salad with salmon…”

27. Revel Restaurant

112 reviews Closed Now

American, Bar$$ – $$$Menu

“Good food, terrible policies”

“Nothing Special”

28. Tocolo Cantina

69 reviews Closed Now

Mexican$$ – $$$Menu

“Many of us ordered the chopped salad th…”

“The Cobb salad and the chicken Taco wer…”

29. Mama Theresa’s Pizzeria Restaurant

153 reviews Closed Now

Italian, Pizza$$ – $$$

1.7 mi

New Hyde Park

“The spinach-artichoke pizza was so good that we came back during the week to…”

“A very good Italian restaurant”

30. Leo’s Midway

54 reviews Closed Now

American, Bar$$ – $$$

“PERFECT! Easy to get to and Food…”

“Great food and drinks, fun atmosphere!”